Research
What we believe, and what we have found.
Six things we believe and six things we have found, the failures included. The ten platforms we study, and how we tell a good trend from a bad one. Every real figure on this page is a count of Wikipedia pageviews, a measure of attention.
- 3
- tests with the rules written down first. One passed, one failed and one was inconclusive.
- 52
- new Wikipedia topics in the second test: 28 German and 24 Swedish. 47 of them had days to grade.
- 10
- platforms with a reader built. Two are live.
- None
- No sales outcome has been measured yet.
Six theses
What we believe.
Attention is not sales.
A view, a search or a post shows that people are paying attention. None of them is an order. Every source we read measures attention, so we report attention and say so. The step from attention to sales can only be measured where the orders are, in a shop.
Most rises fade.
Interest in a topic swings around its own seasonal norm. In 82 Wikipedia topics we had already studied, about a quarter of a month’s rise was given back the next month. That is a look back at topics we had already studied, not a test, and part of the pull back is day-to-day noise. A spike on a chart is usually not followed by interest that holds.
A rise counts only if it lasts.
We read a rise on the day it shows, and then we look again two weeks later. Only a rise whose level still holds is worth a closer look. We judge the outcome over the eight weeks after that check.
Beat the simple rival first.
A method is only interesting if it beats the simplest rule that could work. For ranking which topics will gain attention, last year is the hardest rival: the same weeks a year earlier say a lot about the next few. Our first grade did not beat it, and we say so.
Show the work, failures included.
Every number on this page comes from a file in our repository, and every result is computed by code there. For each test we write the rules down before we compute any result, run it once and publish the outcome, pass or fail.
Use each source only as its rights allow.
For every source we record six rights: to collect, store, analyse with AI, train on, show and sell. Unknown counts as no. Today only Wikipedia’s pageview counts may be shown in public, which is why every real chart on this page is drawn from them.
Six findings, with their limits
What we have found.
Finding 01
Rises that still held two weeks later went on to hold in a little over half of cases in Swedish and six in ten in German. Attention only.
We wrote the rules down, then fetched 52 new Wikipedia topics and ran the test once. Of rises read on the day, about a third were followed by lasting interest. Of rises whose level still held two weeks later, a little over half were in Swedish and six in ten in German. A simpler rule, picking what did well a year earlier, came close: 52% in German and 45% in Swedish. Any day at random gave about one in five. That is a result about attention. It says nothing yet about sales.
EditionGerman Wikipedia: 28 topics; 13,609 graded days.
Real data · Wikipedia pageviews · pre-registered test, one run on 8 Nov 2026Share that held, with its intervalThe share of cases whose interest over days 15 to 70 after the reading was at least 1.25 times the earlier level. The window is the same for every rule. - Any graded day (base rate): 18.8% of 13,609 cases went on to hold (95% interval 15.7% to 21.9%). German Wikipedia.
- Rise read on the day (single signal): 31.0% of 1,852 cases went on to hold (95% interval 27.5% to 34.3%). German Wikipedia.
- Rise read and level still held two weeks later (confirmed): 59.1% of 447 cases went on to hold (95% interval 54.6% to 63.2%). German Wikipedia.
- A winner one year earlier (seasonal naive): 52.2% of 2,367 cases went on to hold (95% interval 44.2% to 58.8%). German Wikipedia.
- The value, with its 95% interval
- Any graded day, 18.8%
Rise read and level still held two weeks later (confirmed): 59.1% of 447 cases went on to hold (95% interval 54.6% to 63.2%). German Wikipedia. Source key: editions.de.wikipedia.point.confirmed
Show as a table
German Wikipedia: share of cases that went on to hold, by rule Rule Held 95% interval Any graded day 18.8% 15.7% to 21.9% Rise read on the day 31.0% 27.5% to 34.3% Rise read, and still held two weeks later 59.1% 54.6% to 63.2% A winner one year earlier 52.2% 44.2% to 58.8% Source: research/grade-backtest-2026-11/results-v2.json, key editions.de.wikipedia, computed by scripts/grade_v2_run.py; one run on 8 November 2026, intervals from 1,000 resamples.
Real data · Wikipedia pageviews · pre-registered test, one run on 8 Nov 2026How real rises endedThe same cases, sorted into the five outcome tiers. All four rules are shown, the two rivals included. Source: research/grade-backtest-2026-11/results-v2.json, key editions.de.wikipedia, computed by scripts/grade_v2_run.py; one run on 8 November 2026, intervals from 1,000 resamples.
The test we had written down, confirmed against read on the day: passes in both editions.
Limits: this is attention, not sales. Part of the gain comes from waiting itself, because a level that has held for two weeks tends to keep holding; the plain rival “the level held, with no signal” was not tested. The confirmed rule acts two weeks later and rarely (447 of 13,609 German graded days). Against “a winner one year earlier”, the confirmed rule leads by +6.8 points in German (interval +0.2 to +14.1) and by +9.1 in Swedish (−3.7 to +20.5, which includes zero): last year’s outcome alone gets most of the way. The Swedish intervals rest on 17 topics. 52 topics were picked by hand, and cases from one topic overlap in time, so the intervals are likely too narrow. One run.
Finding 02
Our first grade showed no skill.
Our first grade ranked the next four weeks of attention less well than a rule that just looks at last year. We had set the bar before the test, and the grade missed it. We kept the result and then tested a different rule (finding 01).
Real data · Wikipedia pageviews · pre-registered test, one run on 5 Nov 2026The grade against its rivalsHow well each rule ranked the next 28 days of Wikipedia attention, as a rank correlation: 1 means the same order and 0 means no relation. Higher is better; the grade had to clear the bar. - The 0 to 10 grade: rank correlation 0.256 with the next 28 days (95% interval 0.222 to 0.290), over 3,660 pairs.
- The plain ratio (last weeks over the weeks before): rank correlation 0.368 with the next 28 days (95% interval 0.328 to 0.410), over 3,660 pairs.
- Last year's same change (seasonal naive): rank correlation 0.427 with the next 28 days (95% interval 0.334 to 0.521), over 3,660 pairs.
- The value, with its 95% interval
- The bar the grade had to clear, 0.477
The 0 to 10 grade: rank correlation 0.256 with the next 28 days (95% interval 0.222 to 0.290), over 3,660 pairs. Source key: test.spearman.grade
Show as a table
Rank correlation with the next 28 days, test years 2023 to 2026 Rule Rank correlation 95% interval The 0 to 10 grade 0.256 0.222 to 0.290 The plain ratio (last weeks over the weeks before) 0.368 0.328 to 0.410 Last year's same change (seasonal naive) 0.427 0.334 to 0.521 Source: research/grade-backtest-2026-11/results.json, computed by scripts/grade_backtest.py; one run on 5 November 2026.
Verdict, in the result file’s words: no demonstrated skill.
Test years 2023 to 2026: 3,660 pairs, 41 Swedish Wikipedia topics. The grade trailed last year’s change by between 0.068 and 0.284 (95% interval).
Limits: attention only; only larger articles (9,673 of 16,154 test pairs were under the floor of 20 views a day); overlapping windows, so the intervals are narrower than the real uncertainty; hobby topics picked by hand. It neither proves nor disproves the framework.
Finding 03
Most single rises do not hold.
Real data · Wikipedia pageviews · pre-registered test, one run on 8 Nov 2026
Of rises read on the day, 31.0% in German Wikipedia (1,852 cases) and 31.5% in Swedish (944 cases) were followed by interest that held a quarter above its earlier level. A further 18.4% in German and 15.6% in Swedish ended a tenth to a quarter up, which is mid tier. The landing page gives the first two figures, with the market and the cost of a parcel beside them: why this should exist.
Source: research/grade-backtest-2026-11/results-v2.json, keys editions.de.wikipedia.point.single and editions.sv.wikipedia.point.single, computed by scripts/grade_v2_run.py; one run on 8 November 2026.
Limits: as for finding 01, which is the same run.
Finding 04
Attention returns toward its norm.
Real data · Wikipedia pageviews · description of articles already seen, not a test
Across 82 Wikipedia topics over the last five years (14,342 pairs), the next 28 days’ change was −0.255 times the past 28 days’ change (95% interval −0.293 to −0.220), plus 0.248 times the same change a year earlier (0.188 to 0.319).
Source: research/speculation/opportunity-lab-v1/results.json, key momentum_all_editions_last_five_years, computed by scripts/opportunity_lab_run.py on 5 November 2026.
Limits: an in-sample description of articles we had already looked at, not a pre-registered test; attention only; hobby topics. The past and the next 28-day changes meet at the same day, so day-to-day noise on that day alone pushes the coefficient below zero; part of the pull back is that noise.
Finding 05
On the day, a news week looks like a lasting rise.
Simulation · not real topics, platforms or markets
In 300 simulated worlds of a one-week surge on every source, 95.3% read as a rise on the day (95% interval 92.3% to 97.2%) and 56.7% scored 8 or more (51.0% to 62.2%); 17.0% passed the two-week check (13.2% to 21.7%).
Simulation · not real topics, platforms or marketsWhy the second check mattersShare of simulated topics of each kind that look like a rise on the decision day, and the share still up two weeks later. Switch between the two: a news week drops. Show- Lasting rise: 69.7% read as a rise on the day (95% interval 64.2% to 74.6%); 52.7% still up two weeks later (95% interval 47.0% to 58.2%). 300 simulated worlds.
- Slow rise: 32.0% read as a rise on the day (95% interval 27.0% to 37.5%); 15.0% still up two weeks later (95% interval 11.4% to 19.5%). 300 simulated worlds.
- Modest lasting rise: 30.3% read as a rise on the day (95% interval 25.4% to 35.8%); 14.0% still up two weeks later (95% interval 10.5% to 18.4%). 300 simulated worlds.
- Fad: 67.3% read as a rise on the day (95% interval 61.8% to 72.4%); 36.3% still up two weeks later (95% interval 31.1% to 41.9%). 300 simulated worlds.
- News week: 95.3% read as a rise on the day (95% interval 92.3% to 97.2%); 17.0% still up two weeks later (95% interval 13.2% to 21.7%). 300 simulated worlds.
- Same peak every year: 28.3% read as a rise on the day (95% interval 23.5% to 33.7%); 11.0% still up two weeks later (95% interval 7.9% to 15.0%). 300 simulated worlds.
- One-day spike, all sources: 7.7% read as a rise on the day (95% interval 5.2% to 11.2%); 0.3% still up two weeks later (95% interval 0.1% to 1.9%). 300 simulated worlds.
- One-day spike, one source: 20.7% read as a rise on the day (95% interval 16.5% to 25.6%); 4.3% still up two weeks later (95% interval 2.5% to 7.3%). 300 simulated worlds.
- No trend: 18.3% read as a rise on the day (95% interval 14.4% to 23.1%); 6.3% still up two weeks later (95% interval 4.1% to 9.7%). 300 simulated worlds.
- Slow fade: 7.0% read as a rise on the day (95% interval 4.6% to 10.5%); 2.0% still up two weeks later (95% interval 0.9% to 4.3%). 300 simulated worlds.
- Lasting fall: 1.3% read as a rise on the day (95% interval 0.5% to 3.4%); 0.3% still up two weeks later (95% interval 0.1% to 1.9%). 300 simulated worlds.
- Share of simulated worlds read as a rise on the decision day
- 95% interval over the 300 worlds
News week: 95.3% read as a rise on the day (95% interval 92.3% to 97.2%); 17.0% still up two weeks later (95% interval 13.2% to 21.7%). 300 simulated worlds. Source key: scenarios.news_week
Show as a table
Simulated topics: read as a rise on the day, and still up two weeks later Kind of topic Read as a rise on the day Still up two weeks later Lasting rise 69.7% 52.7% Slow rise 32.0% 15.0% Modest lasting rise 30.3% 14.0% Fad 67.3% 36.3% News week 95.3% 17.0% Same peak every year 28.3% 11.0% One-day spike, all sources 7.7% 0.3% One-day spike, one source 20.7% 4.3% No trend 18.3% 6.3% Slow fade 7.0% 2.0% Lasting fall 1.3% 0.3% Source: src/components/demo/fixtures/research-preview.json (scenarios) and research/speculation/opportunity-lab-v1/results.json, computed by scripts/opportunity_lab_run.py with seed 20261105 on 5 November 2026; 300 simulated worlds of each kind.
Limits: the numbers describe our simulator, which is calibrated on real Wikipedia attention, not the world.
Finding 06
What we have not done yet.
- No sales outcome has been measured: no shop’s orders are linked to any reading.
- How early a reading comes was defined on 10 November 2026, as a number of days; it has never been measured.
- No model has been run on our data.
- The holiday signal test has not been run: its rules are not frozen yet.
What we have not shown: that any reading leads to sales, or how many days a reading comes before anything else. We will say so when a test of ours shows it, and not before.
Names, status and rights only
The ten platforms we study.
Ten platforms, two of them live today. For each one we record what we read, how we reach it and what its rights allow. Only Wikipedia’s counts may be shown in public, so they are the only platform values on this page. We read no platform through a fake account, a solved CAPTCHA or rotated addresses.
WikipediaShown in public: YesLive
- What we read
- Daily pageview counts of single articles, per language edition (Swedish, German, English).
- How we reach it
- Wikimedia Analytics API, public and CC0; collector on the owner's server.
- Status
- Four collector jobs healthy.
- Shown in public
- Yes
- Read by AI
- No, under review
- Used for training
- No, under review
Google TrendsShown in public: NoLive
- What we read
- The Trending Now list of search terms, with Google's own traffic buckets.
- How we reach it
- Public Trending Now RSS feed (live); the Google Trends BigQuery dataset (reader built, off).
- Status
- Four RSS jobs healthy; the BigQuery reader has no job.
- Shown in public
- No
- Read by AI
- No
- Used for training
- No
PinterestShown in public: NoPaused
- What we read
- Pinterest Trends: a relative interest index per keyword. Stored on the server only, never shown.
- How we reach it
- Pinterest API with a short-lived trial token.
- Status
- Its daily and monthly jobs paused: the trial token expired.
- Shown in public
- No
- Read by AI
- No
- Used for training
- No
TikTokShown in public: NoWaiting on approval
- What we read
- Aggregate hashtag data only: rank, approximate post and view counts. No account, no user.
- How we reach it
- Creative Center public preview (reader kept, jobs paused); Business API discovery (applied for).
- Status
- Preview jobs paused; Business API discovery access not approved.
- Shown in public
- No
- Read by AI
- No
- Used for training
- No
YouTubeShown in public: NoWaiting on approval
- What we read
- Count and reported views of videos that match a search, kept at most 28 days.
- How we reach it
- YouTube Data API; reader built, no job.
- Status
- API audit form submitted; no reply is recorded.
- Shown in public
- No
- Read by AI
- No
- Used for training
- No
InstagramShown in public: NoOff
- What we read
- Hashtag counts (planned). The older public-page reader is disabled.
- How we reach it
- Instagram Graph API hashtag search, which needs Meta's App Review; not applied for.
- Status
- Wanted later, by the owner's decision.
- Shown in public
- No
- Read by AI
- No
- Used for training
- No
FacebookShown in public: NoOff
- What we read
- Page-level counters, only for Pages that grant access.
- How we reach it
- Meta Graph API; adapter built, no job.
- Status
- No job.
- Shown in public
- No
- Read by AI
- No
- Used for training
- No
BlueskyShown in public: NoOff
- What we read
- A bounded sample of public posts that match a search; not a full count.
- How we reach it
- Bluesky public search; adapter built, no job.
- Status
- Public search answered HTTP 403.
- Shown in public
- No
- Read by AI
- No
- Used for training
- No
MastodonShown in public: NoOff
- What we read
- Trending hashtags of one Mastodon instance, with daily post and account counts.
- How we reach it
- Public trends API of the instance, no account and no key; reader built, no job.
- Status
- No job.
- Shown in public
- No
- Read by AI
- No
- Used for training
- No
Hacker NewsShown in public: NoOff
- What we read
- Headlines, points, comment counts and list position of the first stories in one list.
- How we reach it
- Official Hacker News API, no account and no key; reader built, no job.
- Status
- No job; the site's terms bar scraping.
- Shown in public
- No
- Read by AI
- No
- Used for training
- No
- Live
- a job runs on our server and its uploads are accepted.
- Paused
- a job exists but is stopped.
- Waiting on approval
- we have applied and the platform has not approved.
- Off
- a reader is built and no job runs.
Rights come from our rights matrix: an unknown answer, a policy block and an answer under review all count as no.
Five outcome tiers
Good, medium and bad trends.
We grade an outcome, not a hope. Over the eight weeks after the check, we compare interest with where it stood before the rise. Up by a quarter or more is a winner; up by a tenth to a quarter is mid tier; within a tenth either way is flat; down by a tenth to fifteen percent is softening; down by fifteen percent or more is a loser.
Source: python/trendfalcon/opportunity_lab.py (the tiers and their edges), python/trendfalcon/trend_rules.py (1.25 and 0.85), src/lib/success-framework.ts (the words). Edge rule: exactly 0.85 is a loser; every other edge belongs to the tier above it.
The reading and the check that come before the outcome
- Rise read
- The grade is 6 or more, out of 10, on the decision day.
- Confirmed
- 14 days later, the latest week is still at least 1.25 times the level before. This checks the level, not the momentum.
- Selling window
- The 56 days from day 15 to day 70 after the decision day.
- Looks like a winner
- Read as a rise on the day, but gone before the selling window: a fad or a news week.
- Decision day
- The check, two weeks later
- The weeks a shop would sell
- The weeks the level before is read from
- 100, the level before
- 125, the winner line
Winner1.25 x or more
Every source rises together and stays clearly up through the selling window.
Ends at 1.46 times the level before
Day +42: median 148, middle half 146 to 151; 10 of 10 clearly up, 0 of 10 clearly down (100 is each source's level before).
Mid tier1.10 to 1.25 x
Every source edges up and stays a little higher: real, but modest.
Ends at 1.15 times the level before
Day +42: median 112, middle half 109 to 115; 0 of 10 clearly up, 0 of 10 clearly down (100 is each source's level before).
Flat0.90 to 1.10 x
The sources wander around their usual level. Nothing lasting changes.
Ends at 1.00 times the level before
Day +42: median 100, middle half 98 to 104; 0 of 10 clearly up, 0 of 10 clearly down (100 is each source's level before).
Loser0.85 x or less
Every source falls together and stays clearly down.
Ends at 0.67 times the level before
Day +42: median 67, middle half 64 to 68; 0 of 10 clearly up, 10 of 10 clearly down (100 is each source's level before).
Show as a table
| Tier | Day −28 | Decision day | Day +14, the check | Day +42 | Day +70 | Ends at |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Winner | 88 | 145 | 144 | 148 | 143 | 1.46 x |
| Mid tier | 96 | 116 | 115 | 112 | 123 | 1.15 x |
| Flat | 102 | 100 | 98 | 100 | 102 | 1.00 x |
| Loser | 109 | 69 | 68 | 67 | 66 | 0.67 x |
Source: src/components/demo/fixtures/research-preview.json (gallery), built by scripts/build_framework_charts.py with seed 20261108 and almost no noise.
Simulations, labelled as simulations
The same ideas in simulated worlds.
A simulator lets us try the rules on topics whose true course we know. It is calibrated on real Wikipedia attention, and it is not the world: nothing in this section is a real topic, platform or market.
Most sources rise together and stay up.
- Decision day
- The check, two weeks later
- The weeks a shop would sell
- The weeks the level before is read from
- 100, the level before
- 125, the winner line
How many of the ten agree. Above the line: sources at 1.25 x or more of their level before. Below it: sources at 0.85 x or less.
Day +42: median 140, middle half 130 to 146; 8 of 10 clearly up, 0 of 10 clearly down (100 is each source's level before).
- Decision daygrade 8: read as a rise
- Two weeks laterlatest week at 1.55 x the pre-signal level: confirmed
- Selling window1.55 x the pre-signal level: winner tier
Show as a table
| Day | Median | Middle half | Clearly up | Clearly down |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Day −28 | 103 | 96 to 116 | 1 of 10 | 0 of 10 |
| Decision day | 136 | 124 to 149 | 7 of 10 | 0 of 10 |
| Day +14, the check | 155 | 139 to 190 | 8 of 10 | 0 of 10 |
| Day +42 | 140 | 130 to 146 | 8 of 10 | 0 of 10 |
| Day +70 | 150 | 142 to 158 | 9 of 10 | 0 of 10 |
Source: src/components/demo/fixtures/research-preview.json (tenSources), built by scripts/build_framework_charts.py: one typical simulated world of each kind.
Source: src/components/demo/fixtures/research-preview.json (scenarios), computed by scripts/opportunity_lab_run.py with seed 20261105 on 5 November 2026; 300 simulated worlds of each kind.
Interest steps up and stays up. The rise is read on the decision day, the level is still up two weeks later, and the selling window that follows is clearly above where it started.
- What we would have seen
- The simulator's true level
- Decision day
- The check, two weeks later
- The weeks a shop would sell
- The weeks the level before is read from
- 100, the level before
- 125, the winner line
Day +42: we would have seen 173; the simulator's true level was 149 (100 is the level before).
- Decision daygrade 6: read as a rise
- Two weeks laterlatest week at 1.63 x the pre-signal level: confirmed
- Selling window1.52 x the pre-signal level: winner tier
Show as a table
| Day | What we would have seen | The simulator's true level |
|---|---|---|
| Day −28 | 126 | 98 |
| Decision day | 159 | 125 |
| Day +14, the check | 144 | 127 |
| Day +42 | 173 | 149 |
| Day +70 | 160 | 162 |
Source: src/components/demo/fixtures/research-preview.json (examples), built by scripts/build_framework_charts.py with seed 20261107.
Read on.
The market and the cost of a parcel are on the landing page, each with its source.